The article I chose is called “Freedom of Voice” by Maura Stetson. It discusses possible strategies teachers can use to aid their students in developing a writing voice. Stetson believes that nobody can teach voice, despite the fact that it is “the heart of writing.” The article focuses on four main strategies: Institutional vs. Authentic Voice, Freedom of Topic, Audience Awareness, and Linking with Literature. I will be incorporating bits and pieces from each section into my genre transformations.
Originally, I wanted to turn the article into a movie trailer. I thought it would be a really cool and unique way of presenting the information. I am very hesitant to do this. Not because it would take a lot of time or be challenging, but because I’m not sure how well I will be able to explain and demonstrate the “why” behind it all. The movie trailer would be about one teacher’s determination to teach her students about voice and the struggles that come along with that. In the article, Stetson states many times how difficult it is to teach voice. It isn't like teaching someone how to properly use commas, it is developed through student individuality and them finding confidence in their thoughts. Along with that concept, I would convey the importance of student choice in writing and audience awareness. The movie would be tailored for an older audience, ranging anywhere from high school to adult. Sticking to the conventions of a movie trailer, I would only have to include enough story-line to give a general idea of what the movie is about. I am very torn about going with this idea— it could either be really awesome, or completely miss the mark.
Have no fear, I have a back-up plan! If I don’t go with the movie trailer, I was thinking of doing a parenting pamphlet/brochure. One section of the article discusses how voice comes from having freedom and creativity when writing and that students as early as 3rd grade begin to lose this. For whatever reason, upon reading this, I imagined a doctor saying it. As if children were at risk of losing their writing voice in the same way they would be at risk of getting chicken pox without being vaccinated. With that in mind, I began looking up some parenting pamphlets to get a general idea of their conventions. Most of the ones I looked at dealt with learning/medical disabilities, or how to help a child succeed in school. I have a few different options on how to approach writing the pamphlet. I could write it from a teacher/administrator perspective and discuss how parents can implement and promote the use of voice outside of the classroom. Or, I could take a “medical” perspective and discuss “10 ways to prevent early onset voice loss.” Either way, I have to keep in mind that the article was written for writing teachers, but I will be writing for concerned parents. The language and tone I use must be sincere and somewhat empathetic, yet still convey legitimacy so the parents trust what I have to say.
For the genre transformation geared toward a younger audience, I am going to write a blog post/article for high school seniors that are in the process of applying for college. One of the most important parts of the college application is an essay or personal statement. Speaking from experience, it can be extremely difficult to incorporate voice into something of this nature. You want to come across as professional and intelligent, yet still give an idea of who you are. Part of the article focuses on institutional vs. authentic voice. Students develop an institutional voice— the bland, robotic, and formal sounding tone we’ve all used at some point— very early on. Students believe that this type of writing will earn them a good grade, so they stick to the “rules” and avoid taking any risks. My blog post/article would explain the different ways students can incorporate voice into their writing— specifically for their college application essay. I am planning on including many examples to demonstrate each strategy in action, and using a friendly/conversational tone to relate to the students. I think adding some personal anecdotes of my experience in applying for college would also increase the relate-ability factor and add credibility to the piece by showing that I’ve gone through this same experience.
Although my plans for WP3 aren’t 100% solidified, I think I will be able to figure everything out pretty easily. Once I start, I know everything will start to fall into place!
HI!
ReplyDeleteI finished reading your PB and honestly kind of laughed because we finished our PB in the exact same way saying "ehh not so sure how this all sounds to you but it sounds good in my head and I'll figure it out..." kind of thing. I found it really challenging to try to describe in words the brainstorming that was going on in my head, but I actually think your plan sounds really good! I love your idea of writing from a medical perspective because I think there are many clear conventions that describe the medical field perfectly that you could implement in your pamphlet (various diction, intellectual tone, etc.). I also think that you will have no trouble at all carrying this stuff over into a college essay "how-to". You're totally right about how important it is to save your voice in college essays, so it would be really cool if you could even incorporate some of your own essays in as examples! Again, I think you could do some really cool designs and creative aspects to these that would really match their genres and emphasize your academic points!
Dear Alexandra,
ReplyDeleteAfter reading your proposal, I am really excited to hear about your end product because it sounds so interesting and very modern. One thing I am really impressed is the specific details you described for each of your transformation. It is something I struggle with and I really love how technical you went into your pitch. Your brochure idea is really interesting, and I love how you assert a "voice" in their by proposing either an authoritative counselor or a doctor. I also like your blog idea because media is slowly becoming a communication medium among teenagers. Actually I thought about this for my younger audience as well, great minds think alike! Like Amy said, when we are writing for anything, it is important that we don't lose our own voice. Like Amy said, your can do some really cool design with both of your proposal. For your blog, maybe you can make even make each of your article in a shape of a thought bubble or a speech bubble like ones in comics. Overall, well done and creative!
Alexandra,
ReplyDeleteTo start I just wanna say that your creativity and enthusiasm towards the WP3 is actually inspiring! I admire your out of the box ideas, not only in this PB3A, but throughout the entire course. I have full faith that you would be able to make the movie trailer super awesome. It would be something different than most others and I think if you really went for it, that it would no doubt pay off for you. That being said, I also admire your back up plans, and the fact itself that you have backup plans. It shows that you've really been putting thought into this and have thought about all your options. For the blog, I like that its a very real situation that could actually help others potentially get into the college of their dreams. You couldn't be more correct on how important personal statements for college admissions are and your blog idea would be a great way to serve those in need of help. If i had a choice, i'd give your planning an A+!
Good work,
xoxo Jrey